Metaphysical questions
By Amanda Ieraci
Does anything actually matter?
Identity and change- the concept that nothing can exist without an identity and changes can only occur in reality causing an effect on existence
Charles Cooley's Looking Glass self theory, explains that people develop a sense of self based on how they are viewed by others meaning that your actions matter as they will create your identity.
https://lesley.edu/article/perception-is-reality-the-looking-glass-self
Religion and spirituality- the idea that there is a God in which began existence for a purpose
When looked at specifically from the Catholic religion, there are several stories explaining why each and every individual matters. Take the parable of the Good Samaritan for example; the Samaritan stopped to help some one who everyone else passed by. If he would not have done this the vulnerable man likely would have died and the Samaritan's fate could have also been changed. This story shows the many effects one small action can create for the future. This scenario can be associated with the question, where would I be if I had done one thing differently?
https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Luke+10%3A25-37&version=NIV
Mind and matter- the concept that despite the mind not being physical it can still effect the physical world or that people could be dualistic and live on separate from their physical selves.
The theory of dualism refined by René Descartes explains that the physical and psychological self are two separate entities meaning they may be associated but are not dependent on the other. This means that after the physical self dies the psychological self can survive. For anyone who believes in the afterlife that means their soul would find a new destination based on their actions while their physical body was still alive.
https://www.philosophybasics.com/branch_dualism.html
Does God exist?
religion and spirituality- the concept that a divine being is directly engaged with the world whether as one single God or multiple
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4eTKh7xM7DQ
In this interview, a mother and her son describe their experience for God at a time when they were doubting his existence. After dying and coming back to life three separate times after a car accident, the son takes about his experience with going to heaven and he describes things that would have been possible for him to know otherwise.
Cosmology- The idea that the world was created and brought to life as a notion of deity
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t60MBskbNuc
In this Fox News interview with Eric Metaxas, author of the book Miracles; he explains that it is more likely for a divine being to have created this perfectly fit world, that can sustain life rather than to try to find an obscure scientific solution to the question.
Necessity- it is God is necessary as a creator for if existence was not possible for nothing exist then nothing could ever come into existence
the first Ontological Argument made by the philosopher Anselm explains; God's existence is real as he is not a contingent being his existence is not dependent on anyone but himself, where as human existence will always be contingent as it is dependent on the parents of the offspring.
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ontological-arguments/
Does the world really exist?
cosmogony- the study of how the universe was created and the theory of how it continues to be
https://science.nasa.gov/astrophysics/big-questions/how-did-universe-originate-and-evolve-produce-galaxies-stars-and-planets-we-see-today
This is an article from NASA explaining how it was scientifically possible for the Earth to come into existence.
Necessity and possibilities- Necessity and possibility- the idea that for something to be a necessity it must apply to all worlds whereas possibilities may only apply to a few worlds and if it was possible for nothing to exist then nothing ever would
Thomas Aquinas’ Argument from Necessity explains why existence is necessary. In one point of empirical evidence, he proposes that objects are brought into the world and pass all the time. This means at any point they could exist or not exist.
https://philosophy.lander.edu/intro/necessity.shtml
Existence and consciousness- the idea that in order for one to debate existence they must exist with a conscious formed they brain allowing them to do so
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zORUUqJd81M
In this tedtalk Jim Holt explains that the world must exist in a reality whether it is nothing, full or somewhere in between.
What is the meaning of life?
Identity and change- the idea that things cannot exist without an identity and for something reality to change an effect must occur
https://malala.org/malalas-story this link provides the story of the young girl Malala who was at one point a helpless young girl but was then shot for going against her countries beliefs this sparked a change in her that gave her empowerment and a purpose of protecting the vulnerable in life
Free will- the idea that individuals create their own life as a result of making decisions based on thier morals
the book Free Will, Agency and Meaning of Life by Derk Pereboom, explains that is free will helps prove there is a meaning to life. There is a reason why humans choose to react the way they react in pressuring situations that can simply not be predicted ahead of time. Their character is developed from these situations and will help them find their meaning.
Religion and spirituality- the idea that there is at least one divine being that plays a key role in existence and guides individuals
https://www.psypost.org/2018/08/people-who-are-socially-disconnected-turn-to-religion-to-restore-a-sense-of-purpose-to-their-lives-52082 This article explains that having religious beliefs can make people with less social interaction feel that they still have a purpose in life as they are serving and growing in a relationship with God
What is our place in the universe?
Determinism- the idea that every action, event and decision made by an individual conscious is predetermined by an unbroken chain of past occurrences
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-35650616
this article explains the Caste system in India as established in
Manusmriti. It explains that people are born into a certain status in life, this determines what occupation they will be allowed to work and who they will be allowed to interact with.
Cosmogony- The human fascination of how the world came to be in order to help understand our place and role
https://learn.genetics.utah.edu/content/astrobiology/conditions/
This website explains why the Earth is habitable and signs of past life. How the Earth was created effects humans' place in the universe as life without the essential's on this planet as studied so far is impossible. In addition, history often repeats itself and humans must remain evolving to avoid this.
Existence and consciousness- the concept that individuals are either the precievers or the ones being percieved as a result of the conscious not being able to form without existence
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hIdPo-soklY
This video questions that the universe could have a conscious of it's own that would determine life and even without the conscious life would still occur as a result of evolution. this is a theory known as Panpsychism.