Real-World Scientific Thinking
Art verification by Artist
Use techniques and historic contexts to determine reliability
Alone doesn't suffice, needs extensive scientific analysis
Has expertise in field
subject-specific knowledge not available to scientists
Dates of painting, etc
Appears to be prematurely conclusive
Reaching a Conclusion
Scientific method supplements historian method
Sometimes even after science, results are inconclusive
Art Verification by Scientist
Combine scientific method and high technology
Can misinterpret results due to lack of historical context
Unlike artist, considers multiple posisbilities to explain results
Scientists falsify one another's conclusions
Constant state of progress