Knowledge, Truth, and Belief
Correspondence
Natural Patterns, e.g the sun rising in the morning
The sun appears in the sky every morning
consistently
We can conclude that the sun will rise every morning.
This is something we can for sure know.
Except no, the sun doesn't always rise in the morning
Depending on your location, the sun
may not rise for more than 24 hours, known
as a "polar night"
Those who live in these regions would not say that
the sun always rising is true
Knowledge is informed by our environment and the
way we interact with it.
We have prior knowledge that the sun rises daily
Death
Death is a consistently observed pattern in the world.
All things known to be living will, eventually, die.
Historically, there have not been any verifiably
immortal persons
Accurately corresponds with the world; therefore,
we can conclude the fact that "all things will die" is true
The fact that death will come
scares many people. So we form
beliefs about what happens after it
or ways to counteract it.
Belief in Heaven/hell
Reincarnation
Concept of the "Philosopher's Stone"
Alchemical studies to find the
elixir of life
Fountain of youth
Pragmatism
Power of Prayer
A pragmatic view of prayer relies on whether or not
it actually works in practice
Some minor studies have shown prayer to be effective
in healing patients; however, this can be attributed to things like the placebo effect.
People who already believe in prayer are reinforced by this real life evidence. This evidence also effects some non-believers
Reinforced belief in supreme being
Reinforced Belief in heaven/hell
Heavily affected worldview based on the evidence
Despite the evidence, there is still the factor of coincidence.
Just because something happens directly after an event
doesn't mean it was caused by it
Interactions with the world supposedly justify these beliefs; however, they come from a somewhat biased worldview
By attaching ourselves to our beliefs, our capacity for knowledge is limited.
Differing views on the evidence is discredited because it doesn't align with a person's experiences or personal beliefs.
"Practice Makes Perfect"
Many people believe that you have to have talent
in order to succeed in specific areas. From a pragmatic
perspective, this is untrue.
What is talent? it can be said to be a natural ability in any craft or practice; however, "talented" people still have to develop skill. Any talent left unpracticed will deteriorate.
Through interaction with the world, it's easy to conclude that practice does indeed makes perfect. I am an artist and it can be frustrating to hear the unfounded belief when people say they can't draw. Anyone can draw, except not a lot of people put in the effort to develop their skills.
I started out as a very mediocre artist who merely dabbled.
It's taken me 6 years to get to where I am now.
Because, in relation to other things, talent doesn't actually seem to matter it cannot be verifiably true. Practice, on the other hand, shows real results and is consistent enough to be held as true.
I believe practice to be more important
than talent because of my interactions in the world
and how they have informed my approach to my art
Coherence
The "Mandela Effect" AKA False Memory
Widespread False Memories
Nelson Mandela was widely thought
thought to be dead when he was not
Related to misinformation and general ignorance
How do false accounts become common knowledge?
Shows how unreliable both our memories and knowledge
can be.
"Berenstein Bears" vs. "Berenstain Bears"
Many people remember the popular book series
as being called the "Berenstein Bears" when this was never
the case.
Many People agree on a certain spelling of the name
Although this spelling is incorrect, enough people believe it to have been true for it to become common knowledge
Widely believed by many people
Questions the reliability of our supposed knowledge
Climate Change Responsibility
Many people believe that individuals should hold
responsibility for their impacts on global warming and
the climate
Use less gas
eat less meat
Use more renewable products
Recycle more often
Recycling comes after Reducing and Reusing
Much of what we recycle is left in landfill due to
companies having little use for the materials.
Valid beliefs, but who had this thought in the first place?
Corporations forced responsibility onto consumers
to shift focus off of themselves
Pushes to reduce littering and to recycle more are
used as ways to put responsibility on consumers
Many people hold their responsibility
for climate change as true
This belief supplants the focus on industry
contributions to the climate crisis. Although
it's important to practice mindfulness when
it comes to our environmental impact, the blame
should be on companies more so than individuals.
In reality, only around 90 companies contribute
the most to carbon emissions and global warming
Problems with the theory
In many ways resembles bandwagon fallacies
Even though many people have aligning beliefs,
this does not mean that these beliefs are reliably true
Relies on our perceptions of reality to be accurate,
something which is incredibly arguable