BCMA
Metrologic
PROS
Newer Technology
Preferred by majority of nurses (70%)
Better pricing compared to CR3
Reasonable product price
No need to aim (Omnidirectional)
Fast scanning and data transfer
Better look and feel (Comfortable to hold)
Better focal points of 1"-12" .(Range which barcode can be read)
FirstFlash: Few number of tries to scan
Store scanned barcodes into non volatile memory, if bluetooth connection is inactive
Vendor
Greater market share compared to Code Corp
60,000 scanners in the market
More than 30 years in the market
Clients: Wake Forest Health Care
Scan technology: KP qualified vendor
Ranked #1 Scanner Company in VSR POS Survey, 2007 (second time in a row)
Saves Energy
Long Battery Life
Easily remove and replace battery packs without tools - plus remote charging allows for 24/7 scanning
One additional battery with each scanner
Bigger Size ( Less Chance of disappearance)
Operation range of the Bluetooth communication is at least 10 metersbetween the scanner and host system
Presentation Mode that scan barcodes from the stand itself
Scan up to 7 barcodes at once and output data in the proper order
CONS
No Class II laser warning label affixed to the device
Requires Wintel Engineering certification
Battery pops out 90% of the time when dropped from 4ft- Reduce damage to the gun
Not rechargeable without removing battery from the scanner
SYMBOL LS2208
PROS
Solution tested and approved
Many KP departments uses it
CONS
Do not meet functional requirements
Only 1D reading capabilities
CR2
PROS
Solution tested and Approved
Solution working in NCAL
Do not need to reinvent the wheel
Consistent with National standards
Leverages existing vendor relationship
Reasonable product price
CONS
Older technology
Product closer to discontinue cycle
Poor performance compared to the other devices tested
Only 30% of nurses preferred
Need to aim or focus for scanning
Cannot do 24/7 scanning- no remote scanning
CR3
PROS
Upgraded version of CR2
Newer technology
Leverages NCAL's efforts
Consistent with National standards
Leverages existing vendor relationship
CONS
Requires Wintel engineering Certification
Higher product price
User preference almost negative
Bulky and not comfortable
Need to focus or aim for scanning
cannot do 24/7 scanning- no remote charging
No perceived need for keypad entry and LCD display